Updated Nov 17, 2026· 6 min read

Key takeaways

  • Matfer’s carbon steel pans suit cooks who want restaurant-style high-heat searing, a pan that builds a natural seasoning patina over time, and are willing to hand wash and dry it after every use; cooks who want a low-maintenance, dishwasher-safe pan…

Matfer’s carbon steel pans suit cooks who want restaurant-style high-heat searing, a pan that builds a natural seasoning patina over time, and are willing to hand wash and dry it after every use; cooks who want a low-maintenance, dishwasher-safe pan should look at a nonstick or hybrid pan instead.

Matfer Bourgeat is a French manufacturer known for commercial-grade cookware, and its carbon steel line (often referred to by buyers under the Matfer Black Steel name) is popular with both home cooks and professional kitchens for crepe pans, round frying pans, and similar shapes. Carbon steel behaves similarly to cast iron in that it needs to be seasoned, builds improved nonstick performance over repeated use, and reacts to acidic foods if the seasoning layer is thin or damaged, but it’s noticeably lighter than cast iron and heats up and cools down faster, which many cooks prefer for high-heat sautéing and searing.

Seasoning: The Step That Determines Everything Else

A new carbon steel pan arrives with a protective coating that needs to be removed by scrubbing, then the pan needs to be seasoned by heating it with a thin layer of oil until it polymerizes into a dark, slick coating. Skipping or rushing this step is the most common reason buyers report early rust spots or food sticking badly in the pan’s first weeks of use. The maker’s included instructions, or a carbon steel seasoning guide, should be followed closely, and the first several cooking sessions are generally when the seasoning builds up most, so results typically improve noticeably after the first few uses rather than being perfect out of the box.

Sizing and Shape for Your Cooking Style

Matfer’s carbon steel line includes several shapes: flat crepe pans with very low, sloped sides suited to crepes and thin items that need to slide out easily; round frying pans with moderate sloped sides for general sautéing and searing; and some deeper pan shapes for dishes that need higher sides. Crepe pans are a poor substitute for general frying because their low sides don’t contain liquids or loose ingredients well, while a frying pan’s sloped sides make flipping and tossing food easier than a straight-sided pan would. Match the pan size to your typical batch size and burner size; an oversized pan on a small burner heats unevenly, with hot spots in the center and cooler edges.

Handle Design and Heat

Carbon steel pan handles are typically plain steel, welded or riveted to the pan body, with no silicone or other heat-insulating grip in most traditional designs. This means the handle gets hot during stovetop use and in the oven, so a pan holder, folded towel, or oven mitt is necessary when moving the pan, and this should be treated as a given with this style of cookware rather than a defect. Riveted handles can create small ridges on the inside of the pan near the attachment point, which is normal for traditional construction and not a flaw to be concerned about.

Maintenance That Keeps the Pan Performing

After cooking, the pan should be cleaned while still slightly warm, generally with hot water and a stiff brush rather than soap, which can strip the seasoning if used aggressively or frequently. The pan should be dried immediately and thoroughly, since leftover moisture is the primary cause of rust on carbon steel. A thin wipe of cooking oil after drying, especially before storage, helps protect the seasoning between uses, particularly in humid climates. If rust does appear, it can typically be scrubbed off and the affected area re-seasoned rather than requiring the pan to be replaced.

At a Glance: Carbon Steel Pan Shapes

Shape Best for Key stated specs Limits
Crepe pan Crepes, thin pancakes, items that need to slide out easily Very low sloped sides, flat cooking surface Poor for liquids or foods with loose ingredients
Round frying pan General sautéing, searing, everyday cooking Moderate sloped sides, range of diameters Requires seasoning maintenance like all carbon steel
Deeper sauté-style pan Dishes needing higher sides, more liquid retention Taller straight or sloped sides depending on model Heavier than crepe or shallow frying pans of similar diameter

Pick This If…

Your situation Recommended shape/approach
You want to make crepes or thin pancakes regularly Crepe pan
You want one versatile pan for searing, eggs, and sautéing Round frying pan, sized to your typical burner and batch size
You cook dishes with more liquid or loose ingredients A deeper sauté-style carbon steel pan, or a separate sauté pan entirely
You want minimal maintenance and dishwasher convenience Skip carbon steel; choose a nonstick or hybrid pan instead

A Few Alternatives Worth Knowing About

Cast iron skillets offer similar seasoning-based nonstick performance with even more heat retention, at the cost of significantly more weight and slower heat response than carbon steel. Hybrid stainless/nonstick pans need no seasoning and tolerate dishwasher use better, trading away the high-heat searing and patina development that draws cooks to carbon steel in the first place. Other carbon steel makers outside the Matfer line offer similar shapes and performance; differences between brands mostly come down to pan thickness, handle design, and finishing quality rather than the fundamental cooking behavior of the material.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to season a carbon steel pan before first use?

Yes, new carbon steel pans need the factory protective coating scrubbed off and then a seasoning process, typically heating the pan with a thin layer of oil until it polymerizes into a dark, nonstick coating. Skipping this step is the most common reason buyers report sticking or rust in the first weeks of ownership. Follow the maker’s included instructions or a reputable carbon steel seasoning guide for the specific steps and oil type recommended.

Why is my new carbon steel pan sticky or food is sticking to it?

This is normal in the early seasoning period; the nonstick performance of carbon steel builds up gradually over the first several cooking sessions rather than being fully developed out of the box. Using enough oil or fat during early cooks and avoiding very delicate foods like eggs until the seasoning has built up more helps avoid frustration. Performance typically improves significantly within the first few weeks of regular use.

Can carbon steel pans go in the dishwasher?

No, dishwasher use is not recommended for carbon steel, since the detergent and prolonged water exposure will strip the seasoning and can promote rust. Hand washing with hot water, a stiff brush, and immediate thorough drying is the standard care routine. A light coat of oil after drying helps protect the pan further between uses.

Is carbon steel safe to use on high heat?

Yes, carbon steel is generally well suited to high-heat cooking and searing, which is part of why it’s popular in professional kitchens, and it responds faster to heat changes than cast iron. That said, extremely high heat for extended periods on an empty pan can warp thinner carbon steel pans over time, so most makers recommend having oil or food in the pan rather than leaving it empty on very high heat for long stretches. Check the specific pan’s thickness and the maker’s heat recommendations if you plan to use very high heat frequently.

How do I fix rust spots on a carbon steel pan?

Rust can typically be scrubbed off with a stiff brush, steel wool, or a similar abrasive, then the affected area should be re-seasoned following the same process used for a new pan. This is a normal part of carbon steel maintenance rather than a sign the pan is ruined, and most pans can be restored this way repeatedly over their lifespan. Preventing rust by drying the pan thoroughly and immediately after washing is easier than fixing it after the fact.

What’s the difference between Matfer’s carbon steel and a cheaper carbon steel pan?

Differences between carbon steel makers generally come down to pan thickness and gauge, handle construction and attachment method, and overall finishing quality, rather than a fundamentally different cooking material. Matfer’s commercial-kitchen background is often cited by reviewers as a reason for its reputation for thickness and durability consistency. Checking the specific gauge and construction details listed by the maker is more useful than relying on brand reputation alone when comparing carbon steel options.

A
admin
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.